CHAPTER THREE
Though Sunni felt the date hadn’t been particularly bad, it hadn’t been good either. It only confirmed what she always believed, that she and Aaron were better off as friends - having sex didn’t really change anything. She rolled down her window and turned off the air conditioner, wanting the cool night breeze to hit her skin instead.
“My place or yours?” Aaron asked, smiling.
“We can go to yours.” She replied absently, more interested in how her hand pretended to ride the waves of the breeze. Since Sierra was usually out, they spent more time in her bedroom, watching movies or playing video games.
Aaron pulled into his apartment complex and parked his car. “We’re home.”
Sunni paused for a second, but got out of the car - he’d announce their return to places they’d been before, but considering that this was a date, it felt weird to hear him say it. Maybe she was reading too much into it, but it sounded like something someone in a relationship would say - like a couple.
Ew.
He unlocked the door and stepped back, sweeping his arm and bowing. “After you, milady.”
She grinned and curtsied, “Why thank you, kind sir.”
As usual, his apartment was impeccable. Everything was had its place, and usually stayed in that place. It was so neat and tidy that she often wondered how the hell he could stand to step foot into her wild mess of a room. Without being asked, she wandered into the kitchen and yanked the refrigerator open, scouting for something to drink and nibble on. “You’re gonna put on a movie, right?”
“Um... Yeah, sure.” She heard the TV click on. “What do you want to watch?”
She thought about it. “Something funny? Something with action. Ooh! The Avengers!”
“What about something like... Titanic?”
She stood up and turned around, peering over the kitchen island to stare at him. “What the fuck? No. I hate Titanic.”
“Why? It’s a classic.” Aaron looked genuinely confused. “I mean, with all the sappy Disney princess movies you watch, shouldn’t this be right up your alley?”
She frowned, “It doesn’t have a happy ending!”
He shrugged, “So? Not everything has a happy ending, Sunni. That’s how life works.”
She couldn’t think of something to say back to that. She tried not to get upset, forced herself to swallow her angry thoughts. “I don’t want to watch that.”
“What about... Love & Basketball?”
“That’s fine.” She muttered, yanking out a Smirnoff and frozen pizza. As he set it up, neither of them said a word to each other. She wondered if maybe he was upset with her, but couldn’t think of anything she’d done wrong. Men. So complicated. Once the pizza was done, she slinked over to the couch and sat down, tucking her feet under her body and sipped from her bottle.
Aaron sat down next to her and put his arm on the back of the couch, behind her. She smiled to herself and leaned in. He always did the same thing when he was planning on being intimate with her, so she was sure he wasn’t upset. She leaned to him and rested her head on his shoulder. “I haven’t watched this in a while.”
“Me either.” She bit into a slice of pizza. “It’s weird to think that later on, they’ll get together.”
“How so? It’s so predictable - childhood enemies turned lovers. Cliche.”
“What?” She leaned away from him, “They actually become friends once they get a little older. Then later on the romantic feelings develop.”
“Sunni, you’re so...” He paused, trying to find the right word.
“I’m so what?” She prodded, wanting to hear how he would describe her.
“Idealistic.” He finished confidently. “You have the biggest heart, the wildest imagination. I can’t help but adore you.”
She elbowed him playfully. “Yeah, that’s what I thought you were gonna say.” She laughed and sipped her drink again.
His hand found hers as his lips skimmed her jaw. “Sometimes, I love you, too.”
She froze and found herself unable to look at him as butterflies sprouted in her stomach. “T-that’s sweet of you.” She forced herself to keep calm, very mindful of the fact that they were still on this thing he insisted on being a date.
“Do you think maybe we could be exclusive? I’d like you to be my girlfriend.”
‘Oh, no.’ She sat up suddenly, knocking over her drink when she reached for it. “Shit.”
“Don’t worry about it.” He whispered, reaching for her hands. She quickly jumped up from the couch and dashed to the kitchen in search of paper towels. “Sunni, it’s okay.”
“No, it’s not.” She grabbed the paper towels and returned to the couch, blotting out the mess carefully. “It’s a waste of good alcohol.”
“I’m trying to talk to you, seriously.”
She looked up at him from the floor, “About?”
“Us.” When she dropped her head and continued cleaning up the mess, he added, “We’ve known each other for more than enough time. We’ve been intimate for about six months. Don’t you think it’s time we just stopped pretending we don’t love each other?”
She inhaled sharply at the word, causing her to choke on her spit. He bent down and patted her on the back. She nodded her head and held up her hand, signaling him that she was okay. With the liquid mess taken care of, she threw away the soaked paper towels and returned to the couch. She’d hoped that maybe he’d drop the subject in favor of watching the movie, but she was wrong. The second she hit the play button, he began talking again.
“Sunni?”
“Yeah?”
“I love you. I want more than just casual sex.”
Her throat became dry as her anxiety increased. “What else do you want, then?”
“You. Your heart.”
Unable to take it anymore, she shook her head. “Ew, Aaron. Relationship stuff. Let’s just have sex and eat pizza.” She smiled brightly, holding up a slice to his lips.
“Sunni, I’m being serious.” He frowned, grabbing her wrist and moving the pizza away. “Don’t brush me off like that.”
“I can’t help it! You spring this date on me without even talking to me about it, and now you’re all ‘I want to be your boyfriend’. I’m perfectly fine with the way things are between us.” She shrugged, trying to fight to keep herself calm.
“Well, I’m not.” He huffed. “I get jealous when you tell me you went out on a date with someone else. I get jealous when you mention getting flowers from someone I don’t know. I spend so much time with you that it’s sort of ridiculous that we even live separately. I want to start taking steps towards being in a committed relationship.”
The words echoed in Sunni’s head, and each time she heard them, her pulse increased. “I-I can’t do that.”
“Well, why not?”
“I just can’t! I can’t be your girlfriend.”
“Is this because of the Disney comment earlier? You know I can’t stand them.”
“That isn’t the sole reason, but it is a factor - we’re not cut out for a relationship.”
“How do you know? We haven’t even tried to be a couple.”
“We can’t make it through one week without some silly argument, Aaron.”
“We could try, Sunni. I’m willing to try.” She hated the look in his eyes, the pleading, desperate look.
She tried to come up with a sound, logical argument, but ended up with nothing more than a soft whisper, “Aaron, I can’t.”
“You can’t?” He took a step towards her. “Or you won’t?” Her silence told him more than enough. “Damn it, Sunni.” He covered his face and turned away from her. “This is ridiculous! How can you sleep with someone and not love them?”
She didn’t miss how his tone had suddenly changed from warm and inviting, to cynical and detached. “You’d be surprised how easy it is.”
He turned towards her. “Sunni, I can’t keep doing this. I can’t keep pretending we’re nothing more than friends when we act like a fucking couple most of the time.”
“What are you talking about? We haven’t done anything that couples do!”
“What about tonight? We went on a date - this is dating!”
“No, this is something you took it upon yourself to do! You didn’t ask me if I wanted this. You didn’t ask me if I’d be okay with it. You just did it on your own! Now you’re all upset that I don’t feel the same way and it’s your fault! You don’t ever stop and ask for my opinion on things - you just do it!” She took a deep breath and forced herself to calm down. “I am not ready to be in a serious relationship right now.”
“When would you be ready?”
“I don’t know. Honestly, Aaron. I don’t.”
He shook his head slowly. “Then until you do know, I think’s its better if we were just friends.” He put his hands into his pockets and looked down at the stained mess on the floor between them. “No more sex.”
“That’s fine with me.” She whispered, turning to grab her purse.
“What are you doing?”
“I’m going home.”
“Sunni.” He sighed and ran his hand over his face, tilting his head back. “Don’t. We can still watch the movie. And I’ll take you home.”
“I don’t feel like watching a movie anymore.”
“Sunni... Why not?”
With her hand on the doorknob, she paused and glanced over her shoulder at him. “I don’t watch movies with people who are ‘just’ my friend.”
“What?” She didn’t let him finish, instead walking out the door and snapping it shut behind her. She moved quickly and used the app on her phone to arrange for a cab to pick her up. By the time it arrived, Aaron had finally come out. “Let me at least take you home!”
“No thanks. You’ve done enough for me.” She yanked open the car door and got in. She gave the driver her address and sat back in the seat, trying in vain to keep her feelings in check. She refused to cry over it; if Aaron wanted more, then it was best that they weren’t friends anyway. She just hated having to let him go. With a deep breath, she kept blinking her eyes until the tears that threatened to fall went away.
“Hey, are you okay?” The driver asked, looking at her through his rearview mirror.
Surprised by his concern, she gave him a small smile. “No. But I will be.”